The fifth and final season of “You” does just that and shows Joe returning to New York to what seemingly appears to be a happily ever after with his wife Kate (Charlotte Ritchie) and his son Henry. But it wouldn’t be “You” without a new obsession, which comes in the form of Bronte (Madeline Brewer).

"He needed to be as dangerously close to being witnessed finally as a sexual predator that he was," Badgley tells PEOPLE of his character Joe Goldberg

I had to throw that out the window,” Badgley told People, but that change was “a real question” he and the You crew considered ahead of season 5. “That was the question