It was while writing songs for that show that he wrote the first version of “God Bless America.” Perhaps sensing this song was meant for other purposes, and elected to not use it in the show.

His is considered the most powerful and dignified version of “God Bless America.” It remains the gold standard on 161st Street. “I love it,” Judge said, referring to Merrill’s voice.

The organization plays Robert Merrill’s version of the song after switching from Kate Smith’s rendition when the spotlight focused on her past songs that featured racist lyrics in 2019.

It may feel like the anthem, especially when you hear recordings of the late Kate Smith belting it out — her version is a part of Americana. But "God Bless America" is not the anthem.

His is considered the most powerful and dignified version of “God Bless America.” It remains the gold standard on 161st Street. “I love it,” Judge said, referring to Merrill’s voice.