Police believe Herb Baumeister targeted gay men and buried at least 25 victims on $1 million Indiana estate in the 1990s.

The victims of Herb Baumeister are still being identified nearly three decades after the serial killer’s death on July 3, 1996. The Indiana native, a husband and father of three, led a double life.

Emily Krauser Thu, 3 July 2025 at 7:00 am GMT-4 · 9-min read Indianapolis Police Department Herb Baumeister poses for a mugshot. The victims of Herb Baumeister are still being identified nearly three ...