No surprise here, by first-round draft pick Tyler Warren is the Colts' top-rated rookie in Madden 26. He is also the highest-rated rookie tight end in the NFL after being the second tight end taken in this year's draft.

Madden 26 ratings have been released for the entire 2025 NFL draft class, and the Indianapolis Colts' Tyler Warren has the highest rating among tight ends. Warren was the 14th overall pick in this year's draft by the Colts, but was the second tight end taken off the board with the Chicago Bears selecting Colston Loveland at 10th overall.

A lot has to be determined as the 2025 progresses, but here's where the wind is blowing for the Indianapolis Colts in the 2026 NFL Draft.