Jul 7, 2020 · Last night’s episode of WWE Raw saw Rey Mysterio challenge Seth Rollins to an ‘Eye for an Eye Match’ at this month’s The Horror Show at Extreme Rules PPV – a challenge with the Monday Night...

Jul 31, 2020 · At The Horror Show at Extreme Rules, Seth Rollins competed against Rey Mysterio in the first-ever WWE Eye for an Eye match. The match ended when Rollins jammed Mysterio's eye into the point of the ring steps, "popping" Rey's eye out of his head. The final visual saw Rey holding a fake eye in his hand as Rollins puked.

Jan 18, 2025 · Rollins pushed Mysterio's eye into the corner of the steel ring steps. It was a gruesome sight that really sold Rollins' psychological deterioration while setting up Mysterio's comeback. Perhaps most importantly, it brought Dominik Mysterio into the fray.

Aug 8, 2020 · The brutal feud between Seth Rollins and Rey Mysterio saw the two Superstars lock horns in an 'Eye for an Eye' match at Extreme Rules. Unfortunately for Mysterio, he was once again...

Aug 21, 2023 · As Rollins began to brutalize Mysterio in hopes of removing one of his eyes by assaulting him with the steel steps, a barely noticeable eye was seen hanging from Rey Mysterio even though he was covering his face, thus losing the bout. To make things worse, Seth Rollins began to hurl upon seeing Rey Mysterio's eye fall out.

Jul 31, 2020 · But, how did we get here? talkSPORT spoke to Rollins this week about the storyline and he opened up about how WWE managed to pull off the eye-for-an-eye match, the reaction to it and debunked...

Jul 19, 2020 · Mysterio tries gouging Rollins eye on the ring steps until Rollins lands a low blow, Rollins then thrust kicks Mysterio in the face. Rollins follows up by nailing Mysterio with The Stomp on the arena floor, Rollins looks to gouge Mysterio’s eye out and he stops doing so as the referee calls for the bell.

Jul 20, 2020 · At WWE The Horror Show at Extreme Rules, Seth Rollins faced Rey Mysterio in an Eye for an Eye match. Mysterio attacked Rollins from behind to start the match. Still, Rollins took...

Jul 20, 2020 · That plus the guy in the crowd who yelled "You suck Seth Rollins!" every minute or so there were moments in this match that were fucking hysterical

Jul 20, 2020 · The Eye For An Eye Match in WWE Extreme Rules promised that it would only end when one of the two wrestlers of Seth Rollins and Rey Mysterio had lost an eye, and fans are taking to social...